Saturday’s Grade 3 Robert B.
Lewis Stakes is the second of four Kentucky Derby 2025 preps contested at Santa Anita.
The $200,000 event marks the return of 2024 champion
2-year-old Citizen Bull, who captured the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile over this
surface in November. He faces four rivals, including two stablemates, who
will travel 1 1/16 miles. Qualifying points are awarded on a 20-10-6-4-2 scale.
The Robert B. Lewis Stakes is named in honor of Robert “Bob”
Lewis, who owned six champions with his wife Beverly, including their beloved
Silver Charm, Serena’s Song and Folklore. The couple earned the 1997 Eclipse
Award of Merit.
The event is carded as race four of 10, with a 4:28 p.m. EST post time.
Ashley Tamulonis of Coast To Coast and Laurie Ross of Pedigree Power debate whether the Champ will prevail.
Laurie
|
Ashley
|
1. Madaket Road (5-2)
|
The first of the Bob Baffert trio, Madaket Road was
ambitiously placed in the Bob Hope (G3) in his debut and wasn’t disgraced by
his second-place finish. He benefited from a torrid early pace as the
pacesetters fell apart but couldn’t keep pace with Bullard. Madaket Road broke a step slow in his second start facing
maidens. He settled directly behind the pace, angled off the rail and held
off the second-place finisher by a half-length. Madaket Road completed six
furlongs in 1:09.97, with a 12.84-second final furlong, and earned a 94 Brisnet speed Rating. The pretty gray colt recorded three swift five-furlong breezes,
including two in the 59 range. Quality Road’s son is out of Grade 2 winning sprinter
Frolic’s Dream, and Madaket Road is half to multiple stakes-winning sprinter
Bode’s Dream and Grade 3-placed runner Wyeth. Madaket Road can settle off the pace and if they go too
fast early, he could surprise. Contender.
|
Trained by Bob Baffert, Madaket Road
debuted in the Bob Hope (G3), finishing second, beaten by 4 3/4 lengths by
Bullard, who finished third in the San Vicente (G3) in his next start. That
field also included Grade 1-placed McKinzie Street. Madaket Road dropped
into maiden company in his second start and got up to win by a half-length.
Stablemate San Saba was a next-out winner. The Quality Road colt earned a 96
Equibase speed figure in the Bob Hope (G3) and a 94 in his second start.
Frankie Dettori has the mount and will be Madaket Road’s third jockey in as
many starts. Contender.
|
2. Citizen Bull (6-5)
|
Our 2-year-old champ has won three of four starts and
owns two triple-digit Brisnet Speed Ratings. The only mar on his record was a
distant third-place finish in the Del Mar Futurity (G1) after he had a wide trip
behind a quick pace. A $675,000 Keeneland September yearling purchase, Into
Mischief’s son is the third foal out of an unraced Distorted Humor mare who
is a half-sister to 2017 Del Mar Debutante (G1) heroine Moonshine Memories.
This is the distaff line of 1997 horse of the year and champion 2-year-old
Favorite Trick and multiple Grade 1 winner Tiz the Law. Bob Baffert tuned Citizen Bull up with a quartet of
stamina works, including a pre-race five-furlongs in 59 flat. He paired with
last year’s San Vicente (G2) runner-up Pilot Commander. Traveling on
the inside, Citizen Bull used his natural speed while being flanked by his
mate. He urged through the stretch and received a tap on the shoulder while
Pilot Commander was hand-ridden. Contender.
|
Also from the Bob Baffert barn, Champion
Citizen Bull is making his first start since upsetting the Breeders’ Cup
Juvenile at odds of 16-1. Citizen Bull also won the American Pharoah (G1) and
finished third in the Del Mar Futurity (G1). This colt has two triple-digit
speed figures, including the field high of 105 he earned in the Breeders’ Cup
Juvenile. Regular rider Martin Garcia has the return call. Contender.
|
3. Rodriguez (7-5)
|
Rodriguez improved in his second start with an added two
furlongs. He broke alertly from the rail and was lightly pressured through
reasonable fractions of 22.91 and 46.33 seconds for the first and second quarters. He
athletically cut the corner, opened up under a hand ride and was wrapped up
in the final furlong. The Baffert trainee finished a mile in 1:35.91 with an
easy 12.91-second final furlong. He got his three-quarter split in 12.73 seconds. Rodriguez
earned an 87 speed rating. He returned to training with two sharp works,
which were quicker than his pre-race ones. This is a good sign the race took
nothing out of him and that he’ll progress in the R.B. Lewis. He teamed with
multiple graded Getaway Car both times, and in their last breeze,
Getaway Car was urged slightly. By no. 7 first-crop sire Authentic, Rodriguez is a
three-quarter brother to 2017 Southwest Stakes (G3) hero One Liner and
multiple stakes-winning sprinter Provocateur. The extended family includes
2008 Breeders’ Cup Dirt Mile hero Albertus Maximus and Grade 1 winner and
sire Daredevil. Rodriguez has natural speed, but how will he fare when
facing Citizen Bull, who also wants the lead? Exotics.
|
Rounding out the Bob Baffert trio is
Rodriguez, who just broke his maiden on Jan. 4 in his second trip to the
starting gate. In his debut, he dueled stablemate and eventual San Vicente
(G2) runner-up Romanesque and came out on the losing side, finishing 2 1/4
lengths behind that rival. That race produced only one other winner besides
Rodriguez. As the heavy favorite, Rodriguez took his second race gate to
wire, drawing off to win by seven lengths. His speed figure improved from an
87 to a 96. Because of the recency of the colt’s second race, none from that
field have made subsequent starts. J J Hernandez has the return call. Contender.
|
4. Clock Tower (10-1)
|
Clock Tower returns to dirt after a trio of starts on the
lawn, including a victory in the Cecil B. DeMille (G3). By Not This Time, Clock Tower is out of Grade 3 winner
Hot Stones, a stakes winner from seven furlongs to 1 1/8 miles. Clock Tower
has inbreeding to the superior mare Mariah’s Storm through her sons Giant’s
Causeway, the sire of Not This Time, and his full brother Freud, Clock Tower’s
second damsire. A confirmed pacesetter, Clock Tower doesn’t have the same
late kick on dirt that he shows on the lawn and hasn’t flashed the same speed
as the Baffert boys. Pass.
|
Trained by Wesley Ward, Clock Tower began
his career on dirt but has since switched to turf. He’s capable on both
surfaces, but he appears to prefer turf. He’s 2: 0-1-1 on dirt and 3: 2-0-1
on turf, with a victory in the Cecil B. DeMille (G3) and a third in the
Bourbon Stakes (G2). Ward had Clock Tower cross-entered in the Cecil B.
DeMille and the Kentucky Jockey Club (G2) and ultimately opted to keep the
gelding on the turf. Ward is 24% wins with a 55% in-the-money rate with turf-to-dirt runners. Gerardo Corrales will get the leg up. Pass.
|
5. Valentines Candy (30-1)
|
Valentines Candy is the “why?” horse in the R.B. Lewis and likely was entered for betting purposes. The career state-bred maiden finally
earned a trip to the winner’s circle in his eighth start, a 6 1/2-furlong maiden claiming event at Los Alamitos. Dazing Candy’s son is out of the winning Harlan’s Holiday
mare Ancient Holiday. His second dam is restricted-stakes placed and owns
the only black type in three generations of this distaff line. Why are they running this poor gelding against a superior
field and crushing him mentally? Nothing sweet about that. Pass.
|
Trained by Jesus Mendoza, Valentine’s
Candy is the salty veteran of the group, with nine starts already under his
girth. He has raced exclusively in California-bred company and didn’t break
his maiden until his eighth start. He enters off an eighth-place finish in
the King Glorious Stakes for Cal breds, ironically earning a career-high 77
Equibase speed figure. Mendoza is 0% across the board in all stakes races, as
is jockey Welfin Orantes. I understand wanting to take a shot, but Valentines
Candy is seriously outclassed. Pass.
|
Final thoughts
Ashley: Eeny meeny miney moe, pick a Baffert colt by the toe
and so on and so forth. As far as I’m concerned, this is a three-horse race,
and it’s just a matter of picking the Baffert trio in the correct order.
As the newly crowned juvenile champion, Citizen Bull
is the one to beat. He can dictate his own terms or sit just off the pace.
Rodriguez appears to be the main threat to Citizen Bull and will be on the
front end of things.
Wesley Ward isn’t known for having Kentucky Derby
prospects but looks to be dipping his toes into the water with Clock Tower.
He already scratched him from one Derby prep, but all systems seem to be a go
for us to see this Not This Time gelding back on the dirt. I will leave him off my ticket, but I would not be shocked to see him run second or
third. Regardless, with only five horses in the field, he’s guaranteed to come
away with Kentucky Derby points.
Laurie:
Eww,
Ashley, I’m not touching Bob Baffert’s toes, and if you grab his colt’s hooves,
you’ll probably get kicked. I agree that it’s a three-horse race. Baffert needs to make a space for
his record 14th R.B. Lewis trophy. He can stick it next to the ones
from 2019 through 2024.
Thirteen of the last 15 3-year-olds who entered the R.B.
Lewis winner’s circle were first or second in their previous start, and most
had two or three starts under their girth. Twelve of them either set or pressed the
R.B. Lewis pace.
The question on everyone’s mind is whether Citizen Bull
will progress as a 3-year-old. Baffert’s 2-year-old champ Game Winner lost his
first three starts at 3, while Baffert’s four other Breeders’ Cup Juvenile
winners had abbreviated careers.
Citizen Bull doesn’t need to be 100 percent to win, as
this is his first stepping stone to bigger and better. He already has 40 Derby
qualifying points, and the same connections own his stablemates. He proved in his debut that he’s scrappy and
will fight in a duel, but whether his stablemates will is to be determined. Madaket
Road was willing to pass tired horses in both starts, but it isn’t the same as eyeballing
a competitor.
This is a jockey race. I don’t anticipate anyone
burning the early gas, and they’ll all be within a couple of lengths of each
other. Clock Tower is a confirmed pacesetter, and Citizen Bull also likes to be
on the front end, but Clock Tower quits when eyeballed. We don’t know whether Rodriguez will rate, but Madaket Road will
tailgate the pace.
I like
how Rodriguez is coming into the race,
and the clue is in his morning works, plus J. J. Hernandez stays on him instead
of Madaket Road. I’m switching things up.
SELECTIONS
Laurie
|
Ashley
|
3.
Rodriguez (7-5)
|
2. Citizen
Bull (6-5)
|
2. Citizen
Bull (6-5)
|
3.
Rodriguez (7-5)
|
1. Madaket
Road (5-2)
|
1. Madaket
Road (5-2)
|
|
|