Evans has played 28 Davis Cup ties for Great Britain and was a substitute when they won their last title in 2015.
However, he was swept aside in the first set by Shapovalov, who silenced the 15,000-strong crowd at Manchester Arena by taking the opener in just 25 minutes.
The Briton, 34, finally got on the scoreboard when he held early in the second set but failed to make the most of two break points at 4-4.
Former world number 10 Shapovalov was able to back up a dominant first set when he struck the decisive blow at 6-5 to take his nation to the knockout stages, which will take place from 19-24 November.
“I’ve thought about it long and hard. I’ll have to think a little more,” Evans told BBC Sport.
“I love competing for my country. I’ve loved every minute of it but sometimes you’ve got to know when to leave.
“It will be a difficult decision but sometimes it’s nice to give somebody else the opportunity and watch from afar.”
Evans has dropped to 178th in the world rankings after opting to miss some tournaments this year to focus on playing doubles at the Paris Olympics with Andy Murray.
“His ranking has gone down so he’s got a lot of things to consider – what is best for him right now and what does he need to have a successful year next year,” Smith told BBC Sport.
“Whatever happens, he’s been an amazing servant for us.”
Carlos Alcaraz was stunned by Casper Ruud in his opening match at the ATP Finals.Carlos Alcaraz suffered a rocky start to his ATP Finals campaign in Turin, exp
Look ahead to day four of the 2024 ATP Finals with The Tennis Gazette, as we look at the full order of play and how to watch live as Alexander Zverev meets Cas
Key eventsShow key events onlyPlease turn on JavaScript to use this featureNow come the coin toss and warm-up. Sinner is giving away a few inches in height to F
TURIN, Italy — Daniil Medvedev was able to “block the noise” following a temper tantrum in his previous match and mov