The 2025 NFL playoffs will conclude on Sunday, February 9 with Super Bowl 59 between the Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles. Kansas City can become the first team to win three consecutive Super Bowls after it outlasted Buffalo in the AFC Championship Game. Philadelphia returns to the Super Bowl for the second time in three years after scoring 55 points in a blowout win over Washington in the NFC Championship Game. The Chiefs are 1.5-point favorites in the 2025 Super Bowl odds from the SportsLine Consensus, while the over/under for total points scored is 49.5. The Chiefs are -128 money-line favorites (risk $128 to win $100), while the Eagles are +108 underdogs (risk $100 to win $108). Eagles receiver DeVonta Smith did not practice on Wednesday or Thursday due to a hamstring injury. Before locking in any Super Bowl 59 NFL picks or NFL prop bets, be sure to check out the 2025 Super Bowl best bets and predictions from SportsLine’s red-hot Vegas experts.

SportsLine has more than 40 hand-picked Vegas experts who excel in multiple spots. The NFL, however, is a strength for the site as SportsLine currently has five total experts who are on NFL runs that have returned $1,900 or more for $100 players and one who has returned more than $2,600. Anybody following has seen huge returns. 

Now, with Super Bowl LIX quickly approaching, SportsLine’s top NFL experts are already locking in their picks. Go to SportsLine to see them all now.

Top Super Bowl 59 expert picks from R.J. White (29-15, +1323)

White is a Fantasy and gambling editor for CBS Sports, consistently crushing against-the-spread picks by going 636-543-34 on his ATS betting picks from 2017-23, which returned nearly $4,900 to $100 players. He also went 101-84-4 (+1366) on all NFL spread picks last season. Additionally, White is 29-15 (+1323) in his last 44 NFL picks and 30-21-2 (+767) in his last 53 ATS picks involving the Eagles. 

He has locked in his best bet on the spread for Super Bowl LIX. The Chiefs are playing in the Super Bowl for the fifth time in the last six seasons, looking for their third consecutive victory. Philadelphia stands in their way after crushing Washington in the NFC title game, powered by Jalen Hurts and Saquon Barkley. The Eagles became the first team to rush for seven touchdowns in a playoff game, and they lead the league in defensive EPA since Week 10. White believes the Super Bowl 59 spread is off by at least one point, which has led to his early bet for this showdown. You can see White’s 2025 Super Bowl expert pick here.

Top Super Bowl 2025 expert picks from Larry Hartstein (156-115, +1693)

A former lead writer for Covers and The Linemakers, Hartstein combines a vast network of Vegas sources with an analytical approach he honed working for Pro Football Focus. He tied for 52nd place (out of 1,598 entries) in the 2022 Westgate Las Vegas SuperContest, going 53-34-3 ATS. Hartstein’s weekly Vegas contest selections form the basis of his NFL best bets column, which is 79-48-2 (62.2%, +25.95 units) since its inception in 2022. Additionally, he is 156-115 in his last 271 NFL prop picks (+1693). 

Hartstein has already bet on Chiefs wide receiver Xavier Worthy to go Over 5.5 total rushing yards (-115). Kansas City’s traditional rushing attack has struggled recently, as Kareem Hunt and Isiah Pacheco are having trouble averaging four yards per carry. Worthy has cleared this total in four of his last five games, so the Chiefs will be happy to get creative again in the Super Bowl. Hartstein has also identified four other player props to target, along with his best bet on the spread. You can see all of Hartstein’s NFL picks for Super Bowl 59 here.

Top Super Bowl 59 expert picks from Matt Severance (37-12, +1938)

Severance is a well-connected writer and high-volume handicapper who has worked in the industry since 2005. After joining SportsLine, Severance quickly established himself as a top expert in multiple sports. He went 121-93-2 (plus $589) during the 2023 NFL season, and he is 37-12 (+1938) in his last 49 NFL ML picks. Severance is also 47-30 (+453) in his last 77 NFL player prop picks. 

He has released an early best bet on a player to go Over his receiving yards total in Super Bowl 2025. This player has cleared his prop total in four straight games and was heavily targeted in his conference championship game last weekend. Severance also points out that he matches up well against the opposing defense, which was evident in the previous Super Bowl meeting between these teams. You can see who that player is here.

Top Super Bowl LIX expert NFL picks from Sia Nejad (63-38, +1950)

Nejad is a trial attorney turned analyst who specializes in the PGA, NFL and college basketball. He further specializes in the DFS and prop market. Nejad had a highly successful 2023-24 NFL season in which he went 79-59-3 (plus $936 for $100 players, every bet 1 unit) at SportsLine. He has maintained that success this season, going 63-38-2 (+1950) in his last 103 NFL picks.  

Nejad correctly hit on his prop bet for the AFC Championship Game, taking Bills running back James Cook to go Over 55.5 rushing yards. He has locked in a bet on the first half total for the Eagles vs. Chiefs in the 2025 Super Bowl. Nejad anticipates a major difference in scoring in the first half vs. the second half, creating value on the total points scored before intermission. You can find all of Nejad’s Chiefs vs. Eagles prop picks here.

How to make Super Bowl 59 against the spread picks

SportsLine’s team of experts also includes Jimmie Kaylor, a former college and NFL player who has covered both leagues for nearly a decade. He has been red-hot with NFL against-the-spread bets, going 31-20-4 (+916) in his last 55 picks. For Super Bowl 59, Kaylor says one team smashes its point total. Anyone who backs this prop could hit it big. You can find out who his NFL picks are for the 2025 Super Bowl here. 

If you are looking for NFL picks, NFL props, or NFL best bets for the 2025 Super Bowl, SportsLine has you covered with its proven team of experts. Visit SportsLine now to see who which props you should back for the 2025 Super Bowl, all from a staff that includes five experts who are on NFL runs that have returned $1,900 or more for $100 players.