The Grade 3 Gotham Stakes
was shortened from 1 1/16 miles to a mile in 2018. Nonetheless, the one-mile affair
for Kentucky Derby 2025 contenders offers
50 qualifying points to the winner.
Despite the giveaway points, the
best finish by a Gotham victor in a Triple Crown race was Stay Thirsty’s
runner-up finish in the Belmont in 2011.
This year’s Gotham spotlights an
intriguing competition among 10 3-year-old colts, with all but one coming in
off a win or a near miss. It’s shaping up to be an exciting face-off between
two unbeaten New York-bred colts, Sacrosanct, trained by Brad Cox, and Sand
Devil, trained by Linda Rice.
Featured
as race 8 of 10, the Gotham post time is set for 4:18 p.m. EST, and the weather
should be clear and cold.
Ashley Tamulonis of Coast To Coast and Laurie Ross of Pedigree Power bat around the contenders, puzzling over
the riddlers and tossing the jokers.
Laurie
|
Ashley
|
1. Scorching (10-1)
|
Scorching takes a shot on the dirt after excellent
efforts on synthetic and turf. Race Lens shows that two of his half-siblings and
his dam have won over dirt and mud up to 1 1/16 miles. Technically, he’s a
winner of two stakes, the Simcoe on Tapeta and Cup and Saucer on turf, where
he lost the head bob but the winner was disqualified for causing
interference earlier in the race. The John Charalambous trainee switches back
and forth between his right and left lead through the stretch, but it doesn’t
affect his performance.
Mo Town’s son is out of Consolidator’s stakes-placed
daughter Samsal. Scorching’s half-brother, Keep Grinding, is placed in a pair
of stakes in Canada, the Grade 3 Marine and Prince of Wales. Scorching’s
second and third dams are stakes winners.
Class could be a concern since Scorching’s dam and
half-siblings competed at tracks such as Finger Lakes, Woodbine, Laurel and
Assiniboia Downs. Scorching does his best as a pacesetter or presser.
Despite his accomplishments, his Brisnet late-pace figures are some
of the lowest in the Gotham field. Pass.
|
Trained by John Charalambous, Scorching will be making
both his 2025 and his traditional dirt debut when he enters the starting gate
for the Gotham. Scorching made his debut on Tapeta at Woodbine, finishing
second in what has become an unproductive race. The colt won at second
asking, breaking his maiden in the Simcoe Stakes. Scorching wrapped up 2024
with a victory via the disqualification of Ashley’s Archer in the Cup and
Saucer Stakes on turf. That race was on Oct. 6, meaning Scorching enters
this race off a five-month layoff. Charalambous is 0% wins with a 25%
in-the-money clip with runners coming off a two- to six-month layoff. He’s
also 1-for-2 in the money with turf-to-dirt runners. Charalambous has just
one career graded victory, which came in 2013. In the last five years, he’s
sent out five runners in six graded events and failed to hit the board in any
of them. Eric Cancel has the mount. Pass.
|
2. Normandy Coast (15-1)
|
Normandy Coast’s Brisnet speed ratings have progressed in
each start, and the road warrior has competed at three tracks. His
maiden victory at Ellis Park produced a next-out winner and a couple of third-place
finishers, and three rivals returned to hit the board after his next outing
at the Fair Grounds. The Eddie Kenneally trainee showed he was willing to
fight when he turned back two challenges down the lane, capturing the optional-claiming allowance event by a neck over rivals on either side. His final time
for six panels was 1:11.81 but with a slow 13.24-second final furlong. By the
second-leading Third Crop sire Omaha Beach, Normandy Coast is out of the
winning Congrats mare Alliteration. His half-sister Kandy Katie is a
stakes-placed sprinter. Normandy Coast has tactical speed. He can rate off the
pace or lead the herd. One knock is that his late-pace figures are on the low
side, but another improvement here can make him competitive. Exotics.
|
Trained by Eddie Kenneally, Normandy Coast enters off a
neck victory in an optional claimer at Fair Grounds on Jan. 11. Normandy
Coast was fourth on debut, finishing 8 1/2 lengths behind the winner and
Fountain of Youth (G2) entrant Keep It Easy. The colt then won at second
asking before taking a 5 1/2-month hiatus prior to his Fair Grounds victory.
Normandy Coast’s Equibase speed figures have improved with each start,
culminating with a 91 last out. Kenneally is just 9% wins with a 27%
in-the-money rate in graded stakes over the last year. Jockey Ben Curtis has
the return call. Pass.
|
3. Calling Card (6-1)
|
Calling Card returns to the scene of his greatest and
only triumph last November, where he tore up a maiden state-bred field by 17
lengths. He completed a mile in 1:36.36 with a 12.63-second final furlong, while
Joel Rosario kept looking back in disbelief with Calling Card under a hold.
The effort wasn’t as good as it looked. Despite numerous attempts, none of
his eight rivals have earned a trip to the winner’s circle in the state-bred
maiden ranks. Trainer Mike Maker took his Calling Card on the road, but the
colt managed a third-place finish at Oaklawn and was no threat in the
Lecomte (G3). By Complexity, Calling Card’s dam Graceful Rage is a half to multiple graded placed
sprinter-miler Tip Tap Tapizar. Grade 1 heroes Mucho Gusto, Peaks and Valleys
and Higher Power are part of the family. Calling Card must duplicate his 93
Brisnet rating to beat this field. Maybe he’ll come calling down the lane,
but I’m not calling it. Pass.
|
Trained by Mike Maker, Calling Card seeks easier company
after finishing eighth in the Lecomte. I didn’t like him in that spot,
but he might be worth looking at this time. His sole victory, a 17 1/4-length
romp against New York-breds, came over this track. Maker has added blinkers
for this race and is 12% wins with a 30% in-the-money clip with first-time blinkers.
Maker is just 7% wins with a 31% in-the-money rate in graded stakes. Kendrick
Carmouche will be the colt’s sixth different jockey in as many starts. Exotics.
|
4. Sacrosanct (3-1)
|
The undefeated Sacrosanct steps up after dominating
state-bred stakes fields by a combined 13 1/2 lengths. Despite his victories, Sacrosanct’s winning margin
decreased in each start from 12 lengths to 1 1/2 lengths and then by a head
in the seven-furlong New York Stallion Series Stakes. But Brad Cox gave Sacrosanct
a break, and the colt has been training consistently at Belmont for the last
month. By second-crop sire Honest Mischief, Sacrosanct is out of the unraced
Unbridled’s Song mare Vibrato. Sacrosanct’s half-sister is a Grade 3 winner
in Puerto Rico. Their second dam is a stakes-winning sprinter.
Sacrosanct runs well fresh, and his best speed ratings
make him competitive. Plus, his unbeaten record should be respected. That
being said, he might have company on the front end. Exotics.
|
Trained by Brad Cox, Sacrosanct in undefeated in four
starts while beating up on New York-breds. He owns three stakes wins and has
a career-best 92 Equibase speed figure. Normally, I would stay far away from
a runner who hasn’t faced open company, but considering that Sacrosanct
hails from the Cox barn, I have to break my own rules here. This is a soft
spot to make his graded debut, and I expect he will run well over a
track he clearly loves. Regular rider Manny Franco has the call. Contender.
|
5. Sand Devil (9-5)
|
Sand Devil is the stronger of the two unbeaten New
York-breds in the Gotham field. After outclassing maidens and optional
claimers by a combined 16 lengths, Sand Devil stepped up in the Damon
Runyon Stakes. He dueled through the lane and
stubbornly refused to let his rival pass, winning by a long neck. He probably
could have won by more, and they could have gone around again, but the other
horse wasn’t going to pass. The Linda Rice trainee earned a career-best 97
speed rating, and his 111 late-pace figure tops the field. Sand Devil
traveled seven furlongs in 1:24.66 with a sharp 12.27-second final furlong. When he
destroyed optional claimers at a mile in January, it was a paid workout. The
colt was under wraps down the stretch, and he still recorded a 13.03-second final
furlong, so he has speed to spare.
Violence’s son is out of Mineshaft’s daughter
Mineralogist, a multiple stakes winner from seven furlongs to 1 1/8 miles. Sand
Devil’s half-brother Can You Diggit is a restricted stakes winner at 1 1/8 miles, and his half-sister bore the restricted winning sprinter Acoustic Ave.
Sand Devil’s family has plenty of black-type earners, including his second dam Seeking the Ante and third dam Grade 1 heroine Antespend, dam of Florida
Derby (G1) hero and sire Friends Lake. Sand Devil has a very nice pedigree
and tactical speed. Contender.
|
Trained by Linda Rice, Sand Devil is also undefeated
while racing exclusively in New York-bred company. He enters off a game
victory in the seven-furlong Damon Runyon Stakes, which earned him a field-best
100 Equibase speed figure. In his prior start at the Gotham distance of a
mile, Sand Devil scampered off to a 12 1/2-length victory. Like Sacrosanct,
Sand Devil is one I normally would pass on. But restricted company aside, he
looks good on paper. Regular rider Jose Lezcano will pilot Sand Devil in his
graded and open-company debut. Contender.
|
6. Pagode (30-1)
|
Pagode graduated at first asking over a snowy Turfway
strip, winning a three-way photo. He circled the field six wide and needed
every inch of 6 1/2 furlongs. The Paulo
Lobo trainee earned a 76 speed rating, and his 75 late-pace figure is one of
the lowest in this field.
Constitution’s son is out of the turf mare Pretty Girl, a daughter of Harlan’s Holiday. Pretty Girl won or placed in group or graded stakes in Argentina, France and the U.S. The family is filled
with international black-type earners. He may develop into a black-type earner,
but Pagode is shipping, switching surfaces and stretching out for the first
time against more seasoned horses. Pass.
|
Trained by Paulo Lobo, Pagode is a debut maiden winner.
With Luan Machado aboard, Pagode got his nose down on the wire in a 6 1/2-furlong maiden event at Turfway Park. He earned an unimpressive 72 Equibase
speed figure. Lobo is 0-for-6 over the last year in graded stakes, with a fourth-place
finish as his best result. Machado has the return call. Pass.
|
7. Flood Zone (12-1)
|
After washing out Florida state-breds in a maiden event
by 5 1/2 lengths, Flood Zone switched to Brad Cox’s barn in February. Flood
Zone showed maturity in his second start. First, he pressed the pace three wide.
After engaging the pacesetter, Flood Zone was stuck between horses when a
rival challenged on his outside. Many horses will back out when they are
between horses, but Flood Zone won the battle of wills as the pacesetter
backed down. Down the lane, his outside rival gave up. Flood Zone’s ears were
flickering through it all as he didn’t feel seriously threatened. Flood Zone
completed 6 1/2 furlongs in 1:17.82, with a 6.45-second half-furlong. He earned a 94
speed rating, and his 97 late-pace figure is the second highest in the Gotham
field. Brad Cox gave the bay colt a trio of works at Payson Park, including
two five-furlong moves in 1:02, and shipped to New York early to get
acclimated.
Frosted’s son is out of the winning Curlin mare, Curls
for Girls. She’s a full sister to Grade 2-placed Conquest Curlgirl. The
second generation of this family includes Grade 1 heroine Tiz Miz Sue and
Grade 1 hero Free Drop Billy, who was third in the 2018 Gotham. Flood Zone is
bred to love longer distances. He has tactical speed but is shipping and
facing winners for the first time. Live long shot.
|
Now trained by Brad Cox, Flood Zone finished second on
debut, missing the victory by just 3/4 length. He did win at second asking,
improving his Equibase speed figure from a 72 to a 98. But both races
were against Florida-breds, and neither race has produced a winner aside from
Flood Zone. Cox is 24% wins with a 52% in-the-money rate with runners new to
his barn over the past five years. Cox retained regular rider Reylu
Gutierrez, but the duo have teamed up for only one off-the-board placing in
the past year. Exotics.
|
8. McAfee (10-1)
|
McAfee scratched out of the Jerome Stakes. After
graduating at first asking at Churchill, McAfee showed grit and determination
facing winners at a mile. After tailgating the pacesetters, Emmanuel Esquivel
asked the colt to go through a tight opening on the rail. McAfee complied and
battled shoulder-to-shoulder with Moral, while Optical in the three-path
grabbed the lead. McAffee won the battle with Moral and just missed the
victory by a head to Optical. That one showed nothing in two starts at the
Fair Grounds. The Richard Dutrow trainee earned an 83 Brisnet rating and
89 late-pace figure, the highest in the Jerome field.
Cloud Computing’s son is a half-brother to the
sensational Thorpedo Anna. Their third dam bore Wood Memorial hero and sire
Eskendereya.
If McAfee shows a quarter of the talent Thorpedo Anna has
in a hind hoof, he’ll be competitive here. Exotics.
|
Trained by Rick Dutrow, McAfee has a long way to go
before anyone can consider him in the same class as half-sister Thorpedo
Anna. He did debut a winner at Churchill Downs, drawing off to win a six-furlong
sprint by 3 1/4 lengths. That race has produced a handful of winners, albeit
at the claiming level. He then missed his second win by a head in a starter
race to Optical, who was subsequently 23th in the Lecomte. Lane
Luzzi, who has never won a graded stakes, has the mount. Pass.
|
9. Garamond (8-1)
|
After breaking from post 8 in his Tampa Bay Downs debut, Garamond
willingly cut over and passed horses willingly while traveling up the rail.
He athletically cut the corner and from that point, the race was for second
place as the Chad Brown trainee galloped under the wire 1 3/4 lengths in
front. Garamond stopped the clock at 1:17 with a final half-furlong in 6.49 seconds.
Although the victory was visually impressive, the Juddmonte homebred recorded
a 79 speed rating and 82 late pace figure. Uncle Mo’s son is out of the
unplaced Tapit mare Blue Watch. Garamond’s distaff line is European. His
second dam is European champion 2-year-old filly Special Duty, and the
extended family includes 2018 Breeders’ Cup Mile heroine Expert Eye. Garamond’s
post-race works at Payson Park are quicker than pre-race, in the 48 range for
four furlongs. Like some Gotham rivals, he’s shipping, taking on more
experienced rivals and stretching out simultaneously. Garamond needs to
improve to be competitive here. Pass.
|
Trained by Chad Brown, Garamond is a debut winner. It was
a 6 1/2-furlong mid-level event at Tampa Bay Downs, and he received an 81
Equibase speed figure. The Juddmonte homebred was reluctant to load but
otherwise turned in a professional race. He had no problem running inside
rivals and was kept to the task with mild urging from Sammy Camacho. Javier
Castellano will be aboard this weekend. Pass.
|
10. My Mitole (15-1)
|
My Mitole’s light bulb went on in his third start last
year when stretching to a mile against maiden claimers. Given time off, the
Carlos Martin trainee benefited from the break and showed his connections
some love with a 5 1/4-length score against optional claimers on Valentine’s
Day. After tracking the pacesetter, My
Mitole took over at the one-eighth pole and opened up under his own power under a
hand ride. He didn’t switch leads until mid-stretch but was otherwise
professional. He traveled a mile in 1:39.86, with a 13.03-second final furlong. His
speed ratings and late-pace figures improved in each of his four starts, culminating
in an 86 speed rating and 92 late-pace figure.
By Third-ranked Third Crop sire Mitole, My Mitole is out
of the unplaced Seeking the Gold mare Broad Battle. My Mitole’s half-sister
bore black-type earners Joe, a multiple stakes winner at Laurel,
and Irony of Reality, a Grade 3-placed turf router. My Mitole has tactical
speed and should improve in his second start off the layoff. Exotics.
|
Trained by Carlos Martin, My Mitole has raced exclusively
over the Aqueduct oval. He was second on debut and then fifth in his second
start. Martin dropped him into the claiming ranks for his third start. He
also switched up the colt’s running style to be more forwardly placed early,
and My Mitole responded with a win. He followed that up with another victory
in a starter optional claiming race. My Mitole’s best Equibase speed figure is
an 80, and Martin is 0% across the board in graded stakes over the last year.
Regular jockey Luis Rivera Jr. has the call. Pass.
|
Final thoughts
Ashley:
For me,
this sets up as a showdown between the New York-bred Sacrosanct and Sand Devil.
Both are undefeated, and not much separates them on paper. They both love the
Aqueduct oval and come from high percentage barns. I already talked about their
Equibase speed figures, so let’s look at some different numbers.
Sacrosanct has a career-best 95 Brisnet Speed Rating, while Sand Devil’s top rating is a 97. Sand Devil’s best Beyer Speed Figure is the 93 he earned last out in the Damon Runyon Stakes.
Calling Card’s best race was over the Aqueduct oval,
and Flood Zone, Cox’s other entrant, earned a respectable 94 Brisnet speed
rating in his last start.
I look for Sand Devil and Sacrosanct to mix it up
early. Flood Zone could also go early, and if a speed duel ensues, Calling Card
should be well positioned to pick up the pieces.
Laurie:
Historically, all except two Gotham heroes hit the
top four in their previous start and eight won, including five of the last
six. Most winners made their first or
second start of the year in the Gotham.
Pacesetters don’t last. Pressers, horses in mid-pack and one-run closers fared the best. Horses
breaking from the rail are disadvantaged; only one in the last 15 years
prevailed.
Bet the favorite. Eight won, and only one finished
worse than fourth.
Ashley’s
pace scenario has Sand Devil and Sacrosanct
dueling early, with Flood Zone possibly making it three across the track.
I agree there might be a swift early pace with Sacrosanct
in the mix, but I believe Scorching will join him, and perhaps My Mitole will
press from the outside
Although he raced on the front
end in his last two contests, Sand Devil sat off the pace in his debut. He has improved in each start and is a product of the
prominent Chester Broman and Mary R. Broman breeding program.
Despite
the class move, Flood Zone is a live long shot and can improve. He showed
tactical speed in his debut and has been working forwardly at Payson Park.
McAfee
has a lot to live up to, but he’s in good hands with Rick Dutrow. He’s
another who can sit off the pace and make a run.
If you’re
playing the field, take a closer look at My Mitole and Normandy Coast. Both
could improve for underdog trainers. After all, it isn’t who they are
underneath, but what they do that define them. But My Mitole turns around
in two weeks. I’m going with Normandy Coast. He’s a road warrior who runs his
race.
Yes, I’m
taking a stand against Sacrosanct,
although he could become the bane of my existence. He could show a new dimension
and rate, but Manny Franco is known to hustle them to the lead. Sacrosanct must
post similar numbers to his Bertram F. Bongard victory in his
second start to be competitive with Sand Devil.
SELECTIONS
Ashley
|
Laurie
|
4. Sacrosanct (3-1)
|
5. Sand Devil (9-5)
|
5. Sand Devil (9-5)
|
7. Flood Zone (12-1)
|
3. Calling Card (6-1)
|
8. McAfee (10-1)
|
7. Flood Zone (12-1)
|
2. Normandy Coast (15-1)
|