The Decline of a Once-Thriving Industry and the Growing Discontent Among Floridians

Fla. News Network — Florida’s horse racing industry, a staple of the state’s sports landscape for over a century, is facing an uncertain future. Florida has long been a hub for horse racing, with a rich history dating back to the early 20th century. However, the sport is now facing significant challenges, with racetracks closing and public opinion shifting against it.

Despite its glamour, horse racing has long faced criticism for ethical and animal welfare concerns. Opponents argue that the industry exploits horses for profit, often at the expense of their well-being. Issues such as overbreeding, doping, injuries, and high mortality rates on tracks have fueled campaigns against the sport.

The History of Horse Racing in Florida
Horse racing in Florida dates back to the early 20th century, with the first track, the Miami Jockey Club, opening in 1925. The sport gained popularity in the 1950s and 1960s by establishing major tracks like Gulfstream Park and Hialeah Park. At its peak, Florida was home to over 20 racetracks, hosting thousands of races annually.

The opening of Hialeah Park Race Track in 1926. This historic venue quickly became a popular destination for horse racing enthusiasts and hosted many prestigious races. Other notable racetracks, such as Gulfstream Park and Tampa Bay Downs, followed, contributing to the state’s reputation as a premier horse racing destination.

Florida’s climate made it an ideal location for horse breeding and training. Ocala, in particular, emerged as a thoroughbred breeding capital, producing legends such as Affirmed, a Triple Crown winner. The industry brought jobs, tourism, and significant economic benefits to the state.

Why People Dislike Horse Racing
In recent years, however, the industry has experienced a significant decline. Attendance has dwindled, and revenue has plummeted. According to a report by the Florida Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering, handle (the total amount wagered) has decreased by over 30% since 2010.

There are several reasons why horse racing has fallen out of favor with many Floridians:

• Animal Welfare Concerns: Critics argue that horse racing is inherently cruel, with horses often subjected to grueling training regimens and the risk of injury or death on the track.
• Gambling Issues: The sport is closely tied to gambling, which some people view as a negative influence on society.
• Economic Factors: The high costs associated with maintaining racetracks and training facilities have led to financial struggles for many in the industry.

Why Racetracks Are Closing Around Florida
In response to these challenges, several racetracks have closed or are in the process of closing. Hialeah Park, once an iconic track, ceased racing operations in 2010. Other tracks, like Pompano Park and Tampa Bay Downs, have significantly reduced their racing schedules.

Several factors have contributed to the closure of racetracks in Florida:

• Real Estate Pressures: The land on which many racetracks are located has become increasingly valuable, leading owners to sell for redevelopment.
• Legislative Changes: Recent legislation has decoupled casino licenses from the requirement to host live racing, reducing the financial incentive to keep racetracks open.
• Declining Popularity: As public interest in horse racing wanes, racetracks struggle to attract enough spectators and bettors to remain viable.

Public sentiment has also shifted, with younger generations showing less interest in horse racing compared to previous decades. The rise of alternative entertainment options and changing attitudes toward animal rights have further diminished its appeal.

In 2020, the federal Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act (HISA) was passed to create uniform standards for safety and anti-doping practices nationwide. Florida tracks have been required to comply, but critics argue that enforcement remains inconsistent.

Reevaluating Horse Racing in Florida
The future of horse racing in Florida is uncertain, with many stakeholders calling for a reevaluation of the sport’s role in the state. The Florida Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association (FTHA) has been actively involved in discussions about the future of racing, emphasizing the need for a sustainable plan that balances economic interests with animal welfare concerns8.

Animal welfare advocates, like the Humane Society of the United States, are pushing for stricter regulations and increased transparency. “The horse racing industry has a responsibility to prioritize the welfare and safety of its equine athletes,” said Kate MacFall, Florida state director for the Humane Society

Decoupling: A controversial proposal seeks to decouple live racing from casino and card room operations, allowing gambling facilities to operate independently. This move is fiercely opposed by many in the horse racing industry, who argue that it would severely undermine the sport. (Source: BloodHorse, “Florida Horsemen Oppose Decoupling, See It as Threat to Live Racing,” January 7, 2025

The future of horse racing in Florida may depend on its ability to adapt to modern ethical standards and economic realities. Some industry insiders believe a more sustainable and humane model can keep the sport alive, while others suggest a complete phase-out may be inevitable.

What You Can Do:
If you have concerns about the future of Florida horse racing, or if you disagree with certain industry practices, you can:

• Contact your state representatives: Voice your concerns about animal welfare, economic sustainability, and the overall future of the sport. Find your state representative’s contact information here: https://www.myfloridalegal.com
• Support organizations advocating for horse welfare: Donate to or volunteer with groups like the Humane Society of the United States or other animal welfare organizations focused on horse racing.
• Attend public hearings and meetings: Stay informed about legislative discussions regarding horse racing and participate in the public comment process.
• Patronize tracks with strong animal welfare records: If you choose to attend horse races, research the tracks and prioritize those with transparent and robust animal welfare policies.

Forward Together
The decline of horse racing in Florida reflects broader societal shifts in attitudes toward animal welfare and gambling. As the state reevaluates the future of this once-thriving industry, it is crucial to consider the perspectives of all stakeholders and prioritize the well-being of the horses at the heart of the sport.

The future of Florida horse racing remains uncertain. Addressing the economic challenges, ethical concerns, and competition from other forms of entertainment will require a collaborative effort from industry stakeholders, lawmakers, and the public. The outcome will shape the future of this historic sport and the state’s cultural landscape for years to come.

Thank you for taking the time to read this article! Your thoughts and ideas are important to us. Please join the conversation by commenting and clicking the like, share, and follow buttons. We truly appreciate your engagement! If you have any corrections or story ideas, please email the author at EdmondThorne@proton.me.