Jay Leno has suffered a series of injuries in recent years that have left him looking worse for wear, and Bill Maher wants to know if there is something more going on than simple clumsiness.

On the latest episode of Maher’s Club Random podcast, the Real Time host touched on Leno’s most recent accident in November when the former Tonight Show host fell down a hill while staying at a hotel in Pennsylvania, and was later spotted with a black eye and badly bruised face.

“Did you see what the Enquirer said about your spill?” Maher asked Leno. “Well, it’s a conspiracy theory, since you’ve had three accidents, that you actually have gambling debts, and you’re being beaten up by the mob.”

Leno smiled before responding, “I love the idea that the mob would drive to Greenburg, Pennsylvania, wait outside the Hampton Inn on kind of a sleety, rainy day to throw me down the hill.”

Maher playfully countered Leno’s statement, saying, “That’s not what they’re saying; please don’t mischaracterize the Enquirer. They’re saying ‘throw you down the hill’ was your cover story, and they just beat you up like the mob always does.”